Bale the 4CR in GD said:I can tell you why it would be using Medicinal Herbs instead of coccoon. That's because of a change I recently made since I figure nobody would specifically check the box to use them unless their spleen didn't have any better usage. I came to that conclusion recently while playing a new character with few skills and no spleen familiar. I think that is the right choice.
Would you elaborate please? My knee-jerk reaction is that if I have cocoon and enough MP that casting it would not trigger a restore of MP then it has to be better than herbs that cost meat. If we start using opportunity costs, which befuddle so many discussions of what's best, then if the cost per MP is low enough I could still see cocoon as being best.
I tend to spleen before adventuring so if there is spleen available then it probably means I have nothing better which makes this a philosophy question not a practical one, but... And what's a spleen familiar?
Thanks.